1. In Robert Reich's article, "Why the rich
are getting richer and the poor, poorer" i most definitely agree with the
fact that it shouldn't be okay just for the upper class to be benefiting more
from business than that of the lower class. Reason being is because even though
the upper class has more authority within the business itself, if it wasn't for
the lower class their business wouldn't even be running , so don't you think
they deserve the amount of pay that they put in to keep this business going?
Now in Mike Rose's article the, "Blue-Collar
Brilliance", i totally disagree with the idea that a job that requires
less schooling requires less intelligence, because whether jobs do or don't
require as much schooling as the other they both are very much needed in our
everyday lives as people. With either job they require training, studying and
teaching from others, but just because one job doesn't require as much studying
as the other doesn't mean there isn't any intelligence involved. For example,
both a doctor and a hairstylist require different amounts
of schooling. When becoming a doctor you are required a lot more schooling,
because that requires the lives of peoples put into your hands so why would you
want someone who hasn't been studying for years on what to do and how to do it
during times when it could be life threatening. in comparison, a hairstylist
doesn't need as much schooling because they just work with hair rather than a
person's life. With every job there comes its own specific intelligence
involved to do so. Although i do disagree with the fact that a job that requires
less schooling requires less intelligence i do agree with Rose's point that
certain jobs deserve more earning than the other. And even though both jobs
require a certain intelligence they can't compare on the type of intelligence
needed for the job. Take for instance my doctor and hairstylist example again,
a doctor would deserve more earning than a hairstylist due to the fact that it
has more stuff at stake than that of a hairstylist.
2. I think that both Reich and Rose would agree on the idea thats both
the upper and lower class should be paid fairly since they both had to have
some sort of schooling or intelligence in order to do what ever job it is that
they are doing. But i do feel that Rose would have to disagree with Reich about
how certain job should require fairly more earning than others even if both
jobs require some type of intelligence. Reich feels that those who have jobs
that are really needed amongst most people should get paid more, because not
everyone can do that job.